{
  "text": "美國在8月10日撤掉了\n聯邦政府設備上的\nTikTok禁令\n這條新聞出來以後\n很多人的第一反應很直接\n美國退了\nTikTok扛住了\n中國這次算贏了\n可我把這件事前前後後\n重新看了一遍以後\n反而覺得\n如果最後只落到\n一個誰贏了\n其實有點可惜\n真正值得看的\n是TikTok最後\n既沒有整個賣給美國\n也沒有退出美國\n雙方最後談出來的辦法\n是把一家公司裡面\n原本綁在一起的東西拆開\n美國用戶的數據\n安全內容治理\n包括美國版\n推薦系統怎麼訓練\n怎麼更新\n由美國本地的體系負責\n但TikTok的廣告\n電商營銷\n還有和全球產品\n之間的連接\n並沒有一起被拿走\n字節跳動也沒有完全退出\n所以這件事真正出現的\n不是美國\n放過TikTok\n而是中美科技戰\n第一次比較清楚地\n出現了第三種結果\n公司不一定要整個賣掉\n但敏感權力\n可以單獨切出來\n交給當地管理\n過去大家以為\n只有兩個按鈕\n賣掉或者退出\n現在中間多了一條縫\n而這條縫如果以後\n還能複製到別的公司\n意義就遠遠超過\nTikTok本身\n先把現在的結構講清楚\n2026年1月\nTikTok美國業務\n新的合資安排正式落地\n字節跳動保留\n19.9%的股份\n甲骨文銀湖資本\n和阿聯酋投資機構等\n成為主要股東\n但老實講\n這件事如果只看股權\n很容易看錯\n因為真正重要的\n不是誰手裡有幾成股票\n而是誰能做甚麼\n新的美國合資公司負責\n美國用戶的數據保護\n內容安全\n軟件安全\n以及美國版\n推薦系統的訓練\n測試和更新\n甲骨文負責\n美國的數據環境\n也參與代碼檢查\n但是TikTok\n在美國的廣告\n電商營銷\n以及全球產品連接\n還是留在TikTok\n全球體系裡面\n所以這不是\n美國把TikTok\n整個買走了\n也不是TikTok\n甚麼都沒讓\n雙方真正交換的\n是不同種類的權力\n然後大家一定會問\n那算法到底有沒有賣\n這個問題我覺得\n反而沒有以前那麼重要了\n因為我們很容易把算法\n想成一本秘方\n秘方在誰手裡誰就贏\n可今天一個推薦系統\n真正怎麼影響用戶\n不只取決於那套技術本身\n還取決於拿甚麼數據訓練\n誰有權修改\n誰來測試\n哪個版本能上線\n出了問題誰能暫停\n所以TikTok\n這一次真正改變的\n是我們以後看科技公司\n恐怕不能只看\n這家公司是誰的\n還得看這家公司裡面\n真正能決定事情的權力\n分別在誰手裡\n這個地方講清楚就夠了\n因為接下來\n更有意思的問題是\n美國為甚麼最後\n願意接受這種安排\n如果它真的覺得\nTikTok那麼危險\n為甚麼不乾脆封到底\n答案其實沒有那麼浪漫\n不是美國突然變友好了\n也不是因為\n誰喊話比較強硬\n最現實的原因\n是TikTok已經大到\n美國自己也得算成本\n它在美國有超過兩億用戶\n後面連著大量創作者\n商家和廣告主\n很多美國的小生意\n本來就是靠TikTok\n找客戶賣東西\n如果今天把TikTok\n一刀切掉\n當然字節跳動會痛\n可美國自己的用戶\n和商家也會痛\n這才叫籌碼\n國際談判裡面有\n一個很現實的規律\n你說甚麼不重要\n對方失去你以後\n要付多少代價才重要\n如果一家中國應用\n在美國只有幾十萬用戶\n封掉以後市場上第二天\n就有替代品\n人家為甚麼要跟你談六年\n可能一紙命令就結束了\nTikTok不一樣\n它已經大到趕走它\n本身也變成一個\n需要計算的選擇\n所以這件事真正給\n中國企業的第一個啓發\n不是只要強硬就有結果\n而是沒有籌碼\n強硬沒有意義\n但只有籌碼也還不夠\nTikTok\n另外一個值得看的地方\n是它有辦法\n把自己的價值拆開\n哪些東西可以本地化\n用戶數據可以\n內容安全可以\n美國版推薦系統的\n運行管理也可以\n哪些東西不能一起交出去\n全球商業網絡\n產品連接\n品牌廣告電商\n這些真正能繼續\n創造收入的能力\n這個地方其實很考驗企業\n因為談判最難的\n從來不是讓不讓\n而是讓到哪裡為止\n人年輕的時候\n很容易覺得\n退一步就是吃虧\n後來做久了事情會發現\n有時候退一步並不可怕\n可怕的是你不知道\n自己真正該守甚麼\n最後不重要的東西\n死抓著不放\n真正值錢的東西\n卻慢慢丟掉\n企業也是一樣\nTikTok\n這一次真正做對的\n不一定是\n它守住了所有東西\n而是它至少沒有\n把所有價值放在\n同一個籃子裡面\n一次談判全部清空\n這就把問題帶到下一層\n如果以後其他中國科技\n公司也遇到類似壓力\nTikTok\n這套方法能不能複製\n答案是有些可以\n有些不行\n比較有機會的\n是互聯網\n軟件雲服務\n人工智能應用這一類\n為甚麼因為這些行業裡面\n很多安全風險可以切出來\n比如一家中國\n人工智能應用要進入美國\n美國擔心甚麼\n用戶數據\n會不會被拿回中國\n模型會不會\n拿美國用戶資料訓練\n誰能更新模型\n出了問題誰能停\n如果企業有辦法\n把這些問題單獨放到\n美國本地管理\n建立一套\n美國監管者能夠檢查\n追責的體系\n那事情就有談的空間\n美國未必要\n把整家公司拿走\n它可以說\n商業你繼續做\n但我最擔心的那一塊\n要按照我的規則來\n可如果換成先進芯片\n半導體設備\n某些軍民兩用技術\n就沒有這麼簡單\n因為美國擔心的可能不是\n你的數據放在哪裡\n而是你掌握這項技術本身\n就會改變國家實力\n這個時候你\n就算把服務器放在美國\n也解決不了根本問題\n所以TikTok真正\n可能留下的規則\n不是以後所有\n中國科技企業\n都有第三條路\n而是只要風險\n能夠被切成\n幾個具體的控制點\n就可能出現第三條路\n這是很關鍵的邊界\n因為如果這個邊界成立\n未來科技公司\n會多一種以前沒有\n那麼重要的能力\n我把它叫作可拆\n不是把公司拆散\n而是你要有能力\n把不同風險分開\n美國用戶的數據\n能不能單獨存\n當地團隊能不能獨立管理\n安全系統能不能接受檢查\n出了事故\n當地有沒有人能夠處理\n同時這些安排\n會不會反過來\n把你的全球技術\n和商業體系一起掏空\n以前企業出海\n最重要的是產品做出來\n找到用戶\n以後很可能不夠\n你從產品設計的第一天\n就得想如果有一天\n我要進美國歐洲中東\n這個系統能不能\n根據不同國家的要求\n拆成幾個部分\n有些數據留當地\n有些權限留總部\n有些地方讓人檢查\n但最核心的技術能力\n又不能一次交出去\n你會發現\n出海越來越不像\n單純賣產品\n更像在不同國家\n重新搭一個\n版本的自己\n這件事最大的後果\n就是全球化會越來越貴\n過去全球互聯網\n最舒服的狀態是甚麼\n一套系統\n一個後台\n一個總部\n全世界一起跑\n成本低效率高\n以後可能變成\n到了美國\n有一套美國的數據和治理\n到了歐洲\n又有歐洲的版本\n去了其他市場\n還得重新調整\n品牌看起來還是一個\n裡面卻已經分成很多房間\n每個房間有自己的鎖\n這對大公司還可以\n大公司有錢\n有律師有技術團隊\n有安全團隊\n也養得起當地管理機構\n可中小公司就很難\n一家創業公司\n產品剛做起來\n還沒賺多少錢\n就讓它在三個國家\n搭三套合規體系\n它可能根本撐不住\n所以TikTok\n這條第三條路\n並不代表科技全球化\n從此更容易\n很可能正好相反\n全球市場還在\n但進入全球\n市場的門票變貴了\n而且門票越貴\n大公司越佔優勢\n這個現象蠻值得注意\n我們平常覺得\n監管主要是在限制大公司\n可當監管複雜到\n一定程度以後\n反而可能變成\n大公司的護城河\n因為同樣一套規則\n大公司一年花\n幾億元也許只是成本\n小公司花不起\n就只能放棄那個市場\n所以未來科技競爭的門檻\n可能不只是技術\n還有一整套\n處理不同國家\n監管的能力\n再往後看\n這種變化其實\n不只發生在美國\n中國自己也很\n熟悉類似邏輯\n蘋果在中國大陸\n提供雲服務時\n中國用戶的相關數據\n就要按照中國本地規則\n在當地體系運營\n當然這和TikTok\n今天這套安排\n並不是同一件事\nTikTok牽涉得更深\n除了數據\n還有內容\n推薦系統\n代碼安全\n但兩件事\n背後的方向很接近\n數字時代走到今天\n各國政府越來越\n不滿足於企業一句\n你放心我會保護你的用戶\n政府會繼續問\n數據到底在哪裡\n誰能看誰能改系統\n出了問題誰負責\n所以我覺得\n未來真正改變\n全球科技產業的\n可能不是簡單的脫鈎\n而是一種更麻煩的狀態\n生意繼續全球化\n敏感權力開始本地化\n公司還是全球公司\n錢還是跨國賺\n用戶也可能繼續連接\n但是數據\n算法運行和安全責任\n會越來越被\n各國抓回自己手裡\n這其實比完全脫鈎更複雜\n因為脫鈎很簡單\n你走你的\n我走我的\n現在反而是\n生意還要做\n可我又不完全信任你\n於是雙方只能一直畫邊界\n哪裡歸你\n哪裡歸我\n甚麼能跨境\n甚麼不能跨境\n這才是TikTok\n這件事真正有\n長期價值的地方\n它不是證明\n中美科技戰結束了\n恰恰相反\n它可能說明中美科技戰\n正在從一個很粗的階段\n進入一個更細的階段\n過去爭讓不讓你進\n以後爭你進來以後\n到底能做什麼\n這對美國自己其實\n也不是沒有成本\n很多人會覺得\n美國要求數據留在美國\n代碼讓甲骨文檢查\n那不是很簡單嗎\n其實長期監管一家\n科技公司比直接封掉它\n麻煩多了\n封是一次動作\n管是每天都有事情\n今天代碼檢查完\n明天產品又更新\n這個月算法是這個版本\n下個月又換了\n工程師也會換\n數據結構也會變\n所以美國如果真的\n要靠這種模式長期管理\n外國科技平台\n它自己也得提高監管能力\n得有人看得懂代碼\n有人懂算法\n有人能夠判斷企業\n有沒有繞過規則\n這意味著雙方都要為\n繼續做生意付新的成本\n而這個成本可能就是\n未來全球科技市場\n最真實的樣子\n它不會回到過去那種\n毫無防備的全球化\n但也未必一定走到\n徹底切斷\n中間會出現越來越多\n這種奇怪的結構\n我們不完全信任彼此\n可是我們又捨不得\n完全不做生意\n所以只好一層一層加鎖\n這件事情如果放回臺灣看\n我覺得其實也很\n值得想一下\n臺灣討論科技產業的時候\n很容易盯著一個\n最直觀的東西工廠\n廠有沒有搬\n搬了幾座\n美國又要建多少產能\n這些當然重要\n可是TikTok提醒了\n我們一個很現實的問題\n看產業不要只看東西\n搬到哪裡\n還要看決定權搬到哪裡\n比如半導體\n下一代技術在哪裡研發\n最厲害的工程師在哪裡\n大客戶先跟誰談\n產能最緊張的時候\n誰決定先供給誰\n下一輪投資由誰決定\n這些比單純一座\n廠房的位置更重要\n所以臺灣企業去美國蓋廠\n不代表核心能力\n隔天就沒了\n反過來總部還留在臺灣\n也不代表所有核心權力\n永遠都在\n真正應該看的\n是關鍵時刻還有沒有\n自己做決定的空間\n人到中年其實很容易\n懂這個道理\n房子寫誰的名字\n當然重要\n可是一個家庭真正\n有沒有自主\n最後還要看重大事情\n誰能決定錢誰能調度\n出了問題誰還有退路\n產業也一樣\n有時候真正危險的\n不是東西出去一點\n而是決定權出去以後\n就再也回不來了\n所以放回臺灣的位置看\n未來真正該守的不是\n什麼都不能動\n而是那些一旦失去\n就會讓自己沒有\n選擇的東西\n這也是為什麼\n我覺得現在還不能\n急著宣布\nTikTok的新規則\n已經成功了\n這件事很適合用易經\n裡面的未濟來理解\n未濟不是失敗\n它講的是事情已經\n走到後面\n看起來快完成了\n但新的狀態還沒\n真正站穩\nTikTok現在\n就是這樣\n交易落地\n禁令撤掉\n最危險的階段\n好像過去了\n可是這套安排到底\n能不能變成真正的規則\n我覺得接下來只要\n看三個問題就夠了\n第一個能不能複製\n下一家中國科技企業\n遇到類似問題\n美國還願不願意談\n這種本地治理方案\n如果只有TikTok\n一個特例\n那它就不是規則\n第二個能不能跨政府延續\n美國換一屆政府以後\n這套辦法還能不能繼續\n如果每換一次人\n就全部推倒重來\n那它只是一次政治交易\n第三個能不能經得起\n真正的事故\n平常沒有問題的時候\n任何制度看起來都很好\n如果以後真的出現\n數據爭議算法爭議\n安全事故\n這套本地治理能不能解決\n而不是最後又回到一句\n直接禁掉\n只要這三關還沒過\n現在就不能叫既濟\n最多只能說\n第三條路已經被走出來了\n但是這條路能不能\n鋪成公路還不知道\n這裡順便講一個最近\n很容易被放在一起\n解釋的事情\n最近確實有中國企業\n收到美國關稅退款\n有些金額很大\n但我不會把這件事\n直接解釋成美國突然\n對中國態度變好了\n這一輪退款最直接\n的背景是美國司法裁決\n推翻了此前一部分\n關稅授權\n後面依法處理退款\n它首先是法律結果\n不是美國突然\n送出來的一份禮物\n為什麼這個地方\n要分清楚\n因為我們看國際關係\n很容易把所有\n對自己有利的事情\n都解釋成對方服軟了\n這樣講很爽\n可是很容易看錯下一步\nTikTok也是一樣\n我覺得它真正的價值\n不是證明美國被誰打服\n而是證明一件\n更現實的事情\n當徹底封殺的成本太高\n而企業又不可能\n什麼都不讓的時候\n中間確實可能談出\n一種新的分法\n美國沒有拿到\n最理想的TikTok\nTikTok也沒有保住\n原來的所有控制權\n雙方都讓了一些\n可雙方也都保住了\n自己最不能失去的那一塊\n這種結果看起來沒有\n誰徹底贏了那麼刺激\n但它反而更像\n真正能長期存在的規則\n因為國家之間很多\n穩定的邊界\n就是這麼長出來的\n不是因為突然互相信任\n而是因為彼此都發現\n再往前一步\n自己也要付代價\n所以回到最開始\nTikTok解禁\n當然是一條新聞\n但幾年以後如果我們\n再回頭看\n真正重要的也許不是\n2026年美國政府\n設備上終於又能使用\nTikTok\n而是另外一件事\n過去那道只有\n兩個選項的門\n賣掉或者退出\n第一次被擠出了一條\n真正存在的縫\n生意可以繼續\n但關鍵權力要重新談\n不同市場可能有\n不同的邊界\n這條縫現在還不寬\n能不能走成一條\n穩定的路\n也還沒有答案\n可是只要它真的\n存在過一次\n以後面對類似事件\n我們就可以少問一句\n到底誰贏了\n多問一句\n最後誰還保留\n調整自己的能力\n因為真正的被動\n從來不是少賺一點\n也不是退一步\n而是有一天局勢變了\n你才發現\n自己手裡已經沒有\n可以重新選擇的東西了",
  "language": "zh",
  "duration": 984.0,
  "segments": [
    {
      "id": 0,
      "start": 0.25,
      "end": 1.983,
      "text": "美國在8月10日撤掉了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 1,
      "start": 1.983,
      "end": 3.516,
      "text": "聯邦政府設備上的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 2,
      "start": 3.516,
      "end": 4.65,
      "text": "TikTok禁令",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 3,
      "start": 4.65,
      "end": 5.95,
      "text": "這條新聞出來以後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 4,
      "start": 5.95,
      "end": 7.916,
      "text": "很多人的第一反應很直接",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 5,
      "start": 7.916,
      "end": 9.116,
      "text": "美國退了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 6,
      "start": 9.116,
      "end": 10.25,
      "text": "TikTok扛住了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 7,
      "start": 10.25,
      "end": 11.55,
      "text": "中國這次算贏了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 8,
      "start": 11.55,
      "end": 13.216,
      "text": "可我把這件事前前後後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 9,
      "start": 13.216,
      "end": 14.85,
      "text": "重新看了一遍以後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 10,
      "start": 14.883,
      "end": 15.683,
      "text": "反而覺得",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 11,
      "start": 15.683,
      "end": 17.05,
      "text": "如果最後只落到",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 12,
      "start": 17.05,
      "end": 18.483,
      "text": "一個誰贏了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 13,
      "start": 18.483,
      "end": 19.816,
      "text": "其實有點可惜",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 14,
      "start": 19.85,
      "end": 21.283,
      "text": "真正值得看的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 15,
      "start": 21.283,
      "end": 22.35,
      "text": "是TikTok最後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 16,
      "start": 22.35,
      "end": 24.15,
      "text": "既沒有整個賣給美國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 17,
      "start": 24.15,
      "end": 25.816,
      "text": "也沒有退出美國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 18,
      "start": 25.85,
      "end": 27.75,
      "text": "雙方最後談出來的辦法",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 19,
      "start": 27.75,
      "end": 29.016,
      "text": "是把一家公司裡面",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 20,
      "start": 29.016,
      "end": 31.216,
      "text": "原本綁在一起的東西拆開",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 21,
      "start": 31.316,
      "end": 32.65,
      "text": "美國用戶的數據",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 22,
      "start": 32.683,
      "end": 34.383,
      "text": "安全內容治理",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 23,
      "start": 34.416,
      "end": 35.316,
      "text": "包括美國版",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 24,
      "start": 35.316,
      "end": 36.75,
      "text": "推薦系統怎麼訓練",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 25,
      "start": 36.85,
      "end": 37.65,
      "text": "怎麼更新",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 26,
      "start": 37.65,
      "end": 39.716,
      "text": "由美國本地的體系負責",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 27,
      "start": 39.816,
      "end": 41.216,
      "text": "但TikTok的廣告",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 28,
      "start": 41.216,
      "end": 42.316,
      "text": "電商營銷",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 29,
      "start": 42.35,
      "end": 43.716,
      "text": "還有和全球產品",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 30,
      "start": 43.716,
      "end": 44.916,
      "text": "之間的連接",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 31,
      "start": 44.916,
      "end": 46.716,
      "text": "並沒有一起被拿走",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 32,
      "start": 46.716,
      "end": 49.05,
      "text": "字節跳動也沒有完全退出",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 33,
      "start": 49.05,
      "end": 50.85,
      "text": "所以這件事真正出現的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 34,
      "start": 50.85,
      "end": 51.85,
      "text": "不是美國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 35,
      "start": 51.85,
      "end": 53.116,
      "text": "放過TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 36,
      "start": 53.116,
      "end": 54.283,
      "text": "而是中美科技戰",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 37,
      "start": 54.283,
      "end": 55.716,
      "text": "第一次比較清楚地",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 38,
      "start": 55.716,
      "end": 57.483,
      "text": "出現了第三種結果",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 39,
      "start": 57.483,
      "end": 59.65,
      "text": "公司不一定要整個賣掉",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 40,
      "start": 59.65,
      "end": 60.716,
      "text": "但敏感權力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 41,
      "start": 60.716,
      "end": 62.25,
      "text": "可以單獨切出來",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 42,
      "start": 62.283,
      "end": 63.75,
      "text": "交給當地管理",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 43,
      "start": 63.75,
      "end": 64.683,
      "text": "過去大家以為",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 44,
      "start": 64.683,
      "end": 65.816,
      "text": "只有兩個按鈕",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 45,
      "start": 65.816,
      "end": 67.283,
      "text": "賣掉或者退出",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 46,
      "start": 67.283,
      "end": 69.283,
      "text": "現在中間多了一條縫",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 47,
      "start": 69.283,
      "end": 70.85,
      "text": "而這條縫如果以後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 48,
      "start": 70.85,
      "end": 72.55,
      "text": "還能複製到別的公司",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 49,
      "start": 72.55,
      "end": 74.083,
      "text": "意義就遠遠超過",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 50,
      "start": 74.083,
      "end": 75.35,
      "text": "TikTok本身",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 51,
      "start": 75.416,
      "end": 77.75,
      "text": "先把現在的結構講清楚",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 52,
      "start": 77.75,
      "end": 78.716,
      "text": "2026年1月",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 53,
      "start": 78.716,
      "end": 80.016,
      "text": "TikTok美國業務",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 54,
      "start": 80.016,
      "end": 82.283,
      "text": "新的合資安排正式落地",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 55,
      "start": 82.283,
      "end": 83.683,
      "text": "字節跳動保留",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 56,
      "start": 83.683,
      "end": 85.55,
      "text": "19.9%的股份",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 57,
      "start": 85.55,
      "end": 87.116,
      "text": "甲骨文銀湖資本",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 58,
      "start": 87.116,
      "end": 88.95,
      "text": "和阿聯酋投資機構等",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 59,
      "start": 88.95,
      "end": 90.516,
      "text": "成為主要股東",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 60,
      "start": 90.516,
      "end": 91.216,
      "text": "但老實講",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 61,
      "start": 91.216,
      "end": 92.883,
      "text": "這件事如果只看股權",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 62,
      "start": 92.883,
      "end": 93.85,
      "text": "很容易看錯",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 63,
      "start": 93.85,
      "end": 95.15,
      "text": "因為真正重要的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 64,
      "start": 95.15,
      "end": 97.45,
      "text": "不是誰手裡有幾成股票",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 65,
      "start": 97.45,
      "end": 99.15,
      "text": "而是誰能做甚麼",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 66,
      "start": 99.25,
      "end": 101.05,
      "text": "新的美國合資公司負責",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 67,
      "start": 101.05,
      "end": 103.016,
      "text": "美國用戶的數據保護",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 68,
      "start": 103.016,
      "end": 103.85,
      "text": "內容安全",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 69,
      "start": 103.85,
      "end": 104.816,
      "text": "軟件安全",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 70,
      "start": 104.816,
      "end": 105.75,
      "text": "以及美國版",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 71,
      "start": 105.75,
      "end": 107.216,
      "text": "推薦系統的訓練",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 72,
      "start": 107.216,
      "end": 108.55,
      "text": "測試和更新",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 73,
      "start": 108.55,
      "end": 109.35,
      "text": "甲骨文負責",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 74,
      "start": 109.35,
      "end": 110.75,
      "text": "美國的數據環境",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 75,
      "start": 110.75,
      "end": 112.316,
      "text": "也參與代碼檢查",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 76,
      "start": 112.316,
      "end": 113.25,
      "text": "但是TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 77,
      "start": 113.25,
      "end": 114.483,
      "text": "在美國的廣告",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 78,
      "start": 114.483,
      "end": 115.583,
      "text": "電商營銷",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 79,
      "start": 115.616,
      "end": 117.516,
      "text": "以及全球產品連接",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 80,
      "start": 117.516,
      "end": 118.85,
      "text": "還是留在TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 81,
      "start": 118.85,
      "end": 120.316,
      "text": "全球體系裡面",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 82,
      "start": 120.316,
      "end": 120.95,
      "text": "所以這不是",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 83,
      "start": 120.95,
      "end": 121.916,
      "text": "美國把TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 84,
      "start": 121.916,
      "end": 122.916,
      "text": "整個買走了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 85,
      "start": 122.916,
      "end": 123.916,
      "text": "也不是TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 86,
      "start": 123.916,
      "end": 124.85,
      "text": "甚麼都沒讓",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 87,
      "start": 124.85,
      "end": 126.283,
      "text": "雙方真正交換的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 88,
      "start": 126.283,
      "end": 128.116,
      "text": "是不同種類的權力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 89,
      "start": 128.116,
      "end": 129.516,
      "text": "然後大家一定會問",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 90,
      "start": 129.516,
      "end": 131.216,
      "text": "那算法到底有沒有賣",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 91,
      "start": 131.216,
      "end": 132.55,
      "text": "這個問題我覺得",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 92,
      "start": 132.55,
      "end": 134.65,
      "text": "反而沒有以前那麼重要了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 93,
      "start": 134.65,
      "end": 136.45,
      "text": "因為我們很容易把算法",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 94,
      "start": 136.45,
      "end": 137.75,
      "text": "想成一本秘方",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 95,
      "start": 137.75,
      "end": 139.85,
      "text": "秘方在誰手裡誰就贏",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 96,
      "start": 139.85,
      "end": 141.316,
      "text": "可今天一個推薦系統",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 97,
      "start": 141.316,
      "end": 143.083,
      "text": "真正怎麼影響用戶",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 98,
      "start": 143.083,
      "end": 145.45,
      "text": "不只取決於那套技術本身",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 99,
      "start": 145.483,
      "end": 147.916,
      "text": "還取決於拿甚麼數據訓練",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 100,
      "start": 147.95,
      "end": 149.15,
      "text": "誰有權修改",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 101,
      "start": 149.216,
      "end": 149.85,
      "text": "誰來測試",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 102,
      "start": 149.85,
      "end": 151.316,
      "text": "哪個版本能上線",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 103,
      "start": 151.316,
      "end": 153.25,
      "text": "出了問題誰能暫停",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 104,
      "start": 153.283,
      "end": 154.15,
      "text": "所以TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 105,
      "start": 154.15,
      "end": 155.85,
      "text": "這一次真正改變的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 106,
      "start": 155.85,
      "end": 157.716,
      "text": "是我們以後看科技公司",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 107,
      "start": 157.716,
      "end": 159.25,
      "text": "恐怕不能只看",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 108,
      "start": 159.25,
      "end": 160.616,
      "text": "這家公司是誰的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 109,
      "start": 160.616,
      "end": 162.416,
      "text": "還得看這家公司裡面",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 110,
      "start": 162.416,
      "end": 164.45,
      "text": "真正能決定事情的權力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 111,
      "start": 164.45,
      "end": 166.15,
      "text": "分別在誰手裡",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 112,
      "start": 166.216,
      "end": 167.95,
      "text": "這個地方講清楚就夠了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 113,
      "start": 167.95,
      "end": 168.816,
      "text": "因為接下來",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 114,
      "start": 168.816,
      "end": 170.416,
      "text": "更有意思的問題是",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 115,
      "start": 170.416,
      "end": 171.75,
      "text": "美國為甚麼最後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 116,
      "start": 171.75,
      "end": 173.616,
      "text": "願意接受這種安排",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 117,
      "start": 173.616,
      "end": 174.65,
      "text": "如果它真的覺得",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 118,
      "start": 174.65,
      "end": 175.95,
      "text": "TikTok那麼危險",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 119,
      "start": 175.95,
      "end": 177.85,
      "text": "為甚麼不乾脆封到底",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 120,
      "start": 177.85,
      "end": 179.35,
      "text": "答案其實沒有那麼浪漫",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 121,
      "start": 179.35,
      "end": 181.35,
      "text": "不是美國突然變友好了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 122,
      "start": 181.35,
      "end": 182.05,
      "text": "也不是因為",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 123,
      "start": 182.05,
      "end": 183.483,
      "text": "誰喊話比較強硬",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 124,
      "start": 183.483,
      "end": 184.816,
      "text": "最現實的原因",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 125,
      "start": 184.816,
      "end": 186.116,
      "text": "是TikTok已經大到",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 126,
      "start": 186.116,
      "end": 188.25,
      "text": "美國自己也得算成本",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 127,
      "start": 188.283,
      "end": 190.816,
      "text": "它在美國有超過兩億用戶",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 128,
      "start": 190.816,
      "end": 192.716,
      "text": "後面連著大量創作者",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 129,
      "start": 192.716,
      "end": 194.25,
      "text": "商家和廣告主",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 130,
      "start": 194.283,
      "end": 195.75,
      "text": "很多美國的小生意",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 131,
      "start": 195.75,
      "end": 197.15,
      "text": "本來就是靠TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 132,
      "start": 197.15,
      "end": 198.616,
      "text": "找客戶賣東西",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 133,
      "start": 198.616,
      "end": 200.283,
      "text": "如果今天把TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 134,
      "start": 200.283,
      "end": 201.25,
      "text": "一刀切掉",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 135,
      "start": 201.25,
      "end": 202.883,
      "text": "當然字節跳動會痛",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 136,
      "start": 202.883,
      "end": 204.216,
      "text": "可美國自己的用戶",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 137,
      "start": 204.216,
      "end": 205.916,
      "text": "和商家也會痛",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 138,
      "start": 205.95,
      "end": 207.316,
      "text": "這才叫籌碼",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 139,
      "start": 207.316,
      "end": 208.35,
      "text": "國際談判裡面有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 140,
      "start": 208.35,
      "end": 209.783,
      "text": "一個很現實的規律",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 141,
      "start": 209.783,
      "end": 211.25,
      "text": "你說甚麼不重要",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 142,
      "start": 211.25,
      "end": 212.65,
      "text": "對方失去你以後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 143,
      "start": 212.65,
      "end": 214.816,
      "text": "要付多少代價才重要",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 144,
      "start": 214.816,
      "end": 216.016,
      "text": "如果一家中國應用",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 145,
      "start": 216.016,
      "end": 217.95,
      "text": "在美國只有幾十萬用戶",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 146,
      "start": 217.95,
      "end": 219.916,
      "text": "封掉以後市場上第二天",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 147,
      "start": 219.916,
      "end": 221.05,
      "text": "就有替代品",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 148,
      "start": 221.05,
      "end": 223.283,
      "text": "人家為甚麼要跟你談六年",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 149,
      "start": 223.283,
      "end": 224.95,
      "text": "可能一紙命令就結束了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 150,
      "start": 224.95,
      "end": 225.95,
      "text": "TikTok不一樣",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 151,
      "start": 225.95,
      "end": 227.716,
      "text": "它已經大到趕走它",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 152,
      "start": 227.716,
      "end": 228.95,
      "text": "本身也變成一個",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 153,
      "start": 228.95,
      "end": 230.616,
      "text": "需要計算的選擇",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 154,
      "start": 230.616,
      "end": 232.15,
      "text": "所以這件事真正給",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 155,
      "start": 232.15,
      "end": 234.016,
      "text": "中國企業的第一個啓發",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 156,
      "start": 234.05,
      "end": 236.55,
      "text": "不是只要強硬就有結果",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 157,
      "start": 236.55,
      "end": 238.016,
      "text": "而是沒有籌碼",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 158,
      "start": 238.016,
      "end": 239.416,
      "text": "強硬沒有意義",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 159,
      "start": 239.416,
      "end": 241.516,
      "text": "但只有籌碼也還不夠",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 160,
      "start": 241.516,
      "end": 241.983,
      "text": "TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 161,
      "start": 241.983,
      "end": 243.45,
      "text": "另外一個值得看的地方",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 162,
      "start": 243.45,
      "end": 244.383,
      "text": "是它有辦法",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 163,
      "start": 244.383,
      "end": 245.983,
      "text": "把自己的價值拆開",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 164,
      "start": 246.016,
      "end": 247.916,
      "text": "哪些東西可以本地化",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 165,
      "start": 247.983,
      "end": 248.716,
      "text": "用戶數據可以",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 166,
      "start": 248.716,
      "end": 250.016,
      "text": "內容安全可以",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 167,
      "start": 250.016,
      "end": 251.283,
      "text": "美國版推薦系統的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 168,
      "start": 251.283,
      "end": 252.65,
      "text": "運行管理也可以",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 169,
      "start": 252.65,
      "end": 255.05,
      "text": "哪些東西不能一起交出去",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 170,
      "start": 255.083,
      "end": 256.35,
      "text": "全球商業網絡",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 171,
      "start": 256.35,
      "end": 257.316,
      "text": "產品連接",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 172,
      "start": 257.316,
      "end": 259.05,
      "text": "品牌廣告電商",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 173,
      "start": 259.05,
      "end": 260.516,
      "text": "這些真正能繼續",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 174,
      "start": 260.516,
      "end": 262.083,
      "text": "創造收入的能力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 175,
      "start": 262.083,
      "end": 264.25,
      "text": "這個地方其實很考驗企業",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 176,
      "start": 264.25,
      "end": 265.85,
      "text": "因為談判最難的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 177,
      "start": 265.85,
      "end": 267.116,
      "text": "從來不是讓不讓",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 178,
      "start": 267.116,
      "end": 269.216,
      "text": "而是讓到哪裡為止",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 179,
      "start": 269.216,
      "end": 270.283,
      "text": "人年輕的時候",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 180,
      "start": 270.283,
      "end": 271.25,
      "text": "很容易覺得",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 181,
      "start": 271.25,
      "end": 272.716,
      "text": "退一步就是吃虧",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 182,
      "start": 272.883,
      "end": 274.683,
      "text": "後來做久了事情會發現",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 183,
      "start": 274.683,
      "end": 276.916,
      "text": "有時候退一步並不可怕",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 184,
      "start": 276.916,
      "end": 278.316,
      "text": "可怕的是你不知道",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 185,
      "start": 278.316,
      "end": 280.016,
      "text": "自己真正該守甚麼",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 186,
      "start": 280.016,
      "end": 281.65,
      "text": "最後不重要的東西",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 187,
      "start": 281.683,
      "end": 282.716,
      "text": "死抓著不放",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 188,
      "start": 282.716,
      "end": 284.25,
      "text": "真正值錢的東西",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 189,
      "start": 284.25,
      "end": 285.416,
      "text": "卻慢慢丟掉",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 190,
      "start": 285.416,
      "end": 286.916,
      "text": "企業也是一樣",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 191,
      "start": 286.916,
      "end": 287.416,
      "text": "TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 192,
      "start": 287.416,
      "end": 288.95,
      "text": "這一次真正做對的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 193,
      "start": 288.95,
      "end": 289.65,
      "text": "不一定是",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 194,
      "start": 289.65,
      "end": 291.25,
      "text": "它守住了所有東西",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 195,
      "start": 291.25,
      "end": 292.416,
      "text": "而是它至少沒有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 196,
      "start": 292.416,
      "end": 294.083,
      "text": "把所有價值放在",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 197,
      "start": 294.083,
      "end": 295.316,
      "text": "同一個籃子裡面",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 198,
      "start": 295.316,
      "end": 297.05,
      "text": "一次談判全部清空",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 199,
      "start": 297.05,
      "end": 299.283,
      "text": "這就把問題帶到下一層",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 200,
      "start": 299.283,
      "end": 300.916,
      "text": "如果以後其他中國科技",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 201,
      "start": 300.916,
      "end": 302.65,
      "text": "公司也遇到類似壓力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 202,
      "start": 302.65,
      "end": 303.25,
      "text": "TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 203,
      "start": 303.25,
      "end": 304.95,
      "text": "這套方法能不能複製",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 204,
      "start": 304.95,
      "end": 306.616,
      "text": "答案是有些可以",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 205,
      "start": 306.616,
      "end": 307.65,
      "text": "有些不行",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 206,
      "start": 307.65,
      "end": 308.75,
      "text": "比較有機會的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 207,
      "start": 308.75,
      "end": 309.616,
      "text": "是互聯網",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 208,
      "start": 309.616,
      "end": 310.816,
      "text": "軟件雲服務",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 209,
      "start": 310.816,
      "end": 312.55,
      "text": "人工智能應用這一類",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 210,
      "start": 312.55,
      "end": 314.616,
      "text": "為甚麼因為這些行業裡面",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 211,
      "start": 314.616,
      "end": 316.95,
      "text": "很多安全風險可以切出來",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 212,
      "start": 316.95,
      "end": 318.016,
      "text": "比如一家中國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 213,
      "start": 318.016,
      "end": 320.216,
      "text": "人工智能應用要進入美國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 214,
      "start": 320.216,
      "end": 321.55,
      "text": "美國擔心甚麼",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 215,
      "start": 321.55,
      "end": 322.416,
      "text": "用戶數據",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 216,
      "start": 322.45,
      "end": 323.95,
      "text": "會不會被拿回中國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 217,
      "start": 323.95,
      "end": 324.85,
      "text": "模型會不會",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 218,
      "start": 324.85,
      "end": 326.75,
      "text": "拿美國用戶資料訓練",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 219,
      "start": 326.75,
      "end": 328.25,
      "text": "誰能更新模型",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 220,
      "start": 328.25,
      "end": 329.95,
      "text": "出了問題誰能停",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 221,
      "start": 329.95,
      "end": 331.183,
      "text": "如果企業有辦法",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 222,
      "start": 331.183,
      "end": 332.916,
      "text": "把這些問題單獨放到",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 223,
      "start": 332.916,
      "end": 334.15,
      "text": "美國本地管理",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 224,
      "start": 334.15,
      "end": 334.85,
      "text": "建立一套",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 225,
      "start": 334.85,
      "end": 336.883,
      "text": "美國監管者能夠檢查",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 226,
      "start": 336.883,
      "end": 338.05,
      "text": "追責的體系",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 227,
      "start": 338.05,
      "end": 340.15,
      "text": "那事情就有談的空間",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 228,
      "start": 340.15,
      "end": 341.216,
      "text": "美國未必要",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 229,
      "start": 341.216,
      "end": 342.816,
      "text": "把整家公司拿走",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 230,
      "start": 342.816,
      "end": 343.716,
      "text": "它可以說",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 231,
      "start": 343.716,
      "end": 345.05,
      "text": "商業你繼續做",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 232,
      "start": 345.05,
      "end": 346.75,
      "text": "但我最擔心的那一塊",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 233,
      "start": 346.75,
      "end": 348.516,
      "text": "要按照我的規則來",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 234,
      "start": 348.516,
      "end": 350.316,
      "text": "可如果換成先進芯片",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 235,
      "start": 350.316,
      "end": 351.35,
      "text": "半導體設備",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 236,
      "start": 351.35,
      "end": 352.95,
      "text": "某些軍民兩用技術",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 237,
      "start": 352.95,
      "end": 354.35,
      "text": "就沒有這麼簡單",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 238,
      "start": 354.35,
      "end": 356.116,
      "text": "因為美國擔心的可能不是",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 239,
      "start": 356.116,
      "end": 357.483,
      "text": "你的數據放在哪裡",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 240,
      "start": 357.483,
      "end": 360.216,
      "text": "而是你掌握這項技術本身",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 241,
      "start": 360.216,
      "end": 361.916,
      "text": "就會改變國家實力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 242,
      "start": 361.916,
      "end": 362.65,
      "text": "這個時候你",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 243,
      "start": 362.65,
      "end": 364.616,
      "text": "就算把服務器放在美國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 244,
      "start": 364.616,
      "end": 366.65,
      "text": "也解決不了根本問題",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 245,
      "start": 366.65,
      "end": 368.216,
      "text": "所以TikTok真正",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 246,
      "start": 368.216,
      "end": 369.65,
      "text": "可能留下的規則",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 247,
      "start": 369.65,
      "end": 371.216,
      "text": "不是以後所有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 248,
      "start": 371.216,
      "end": 372.316,
      "text": "中國科技企業",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 249,
      "start": 372.316,
      "end": 373.85,
      "text": "都有第三條路",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 250,
      "start": 373.85,
      "end": 375.25,
      "text": "而是只要風險",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 251,
      "start": 375.25,
      "end": 376.15,
      "text": "能夠被切成",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 252,
      "start": 376.15,
      "end": 377.816,
      "text": "幾個具體的控制點",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 253,
      "start": 377.816,
      "end": 379.816,
      "text": "就可能出現第三條路",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 254,
      "start": 379.816,
      "end": 381.45,
      "text": "這是很關鍵的邊界",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 255,
      "start": 381.45,
      "end": 383.316,
      "text": "因為如果這個邊界成立",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 256,
      "start": 383.316,
      "end": 384.516,
      "text": "未來科技公司",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 257,
      "start": 384.516,
      "end": 386.116,
      "text": "會多一種以前沒有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 258,
      "start": 386.116,
      "end": 387.45,
      "text": "那麼重要的能力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 259,
      "start": 387.45,
      "end": 389.216,
      "text": "我把它叫作可拆",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 260,
      "start": 389.216,
      "end": 390.916,
      "text": "不是把公司拆散",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 261,
      "start": 390.916,
      "end": 392.083,
      "text": "而是你要有能力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 262,
      "start": 392.083,
      "end": 393.616,
      "text": "把不同風險分開",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 263,
      "start": 393.616,
      "end": 394.683,
      "text": "美國用戶的數據",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 264,
      "start": 394.683,
      "end": 395.916,
      "text": "能不能單獨存",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 265,
      "start": 395.916,
      "end": 398.016,
      "text": "當地團隊能不能獨立管理",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 266,
      "start": 398.016,
      "end": 400.116,
      "text": "安全系統能不能接受檢查",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 267,
      "start": 400.116,
      "end": 400.883,
      "text": "出了事故",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 268,
      "start": 400.883,
      "end": 403.116,
      "text": "當地有沒有人能夠處理",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 269,
      "start": 403.116,
      "end": 404.15,
      "text": "同時這些安排",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 270,
      "start": 404.15,
      "end": 405.216,
      "text": "會不會反過來",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 271,
      "start": 405.216,
      "end": 406.683,
      "text": "把你的全球技術",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 272,
      "start": 406.683,
      "end": 408.783,
      "text": "和商業體系一起掏空",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 273,
      "start": 408.816,
      "end": 409.916,
      "text": "以前企業出海",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 274,
      "start": 409.916,
      "end": 412.016,
      "text": "最重要的是產品做出來",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 275,
      "start": 412.016,
      "end": 412.85,
      "text": "找到用戶",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 276,
      "start": 412.85,
      "end": 414.283,
      "text": "以後很可能不夠",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 277,
      "start": 414.283,
      "end": 416.483,
      "text": "你從產品設計的第一天",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 278,
      "start": 416.483,
      "end": 418.116,
      "text": "就得想如果有一天",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 279,
      "start": 418.116,
      "end": 420.45,
      "text": "我要進美國歐洲中東",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 280,
      "start": 420.45,
      "end": 421.616,
      "text": "這個系統能不能",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 281,
      "start": 421.616,
      "end": 423.316,
      "text": "根據不同國家的要求",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 282,
      "start": 423.316,
      "end": 424.65,
      "text": "拆成幾個部分",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 283,
      "start": 424.65,
      "end": 426.016,
      "text": "有些數據留當地",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 284,
      "start": 426.016,
      "end": 427.816,
      "text": "有些權限留總部",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 285,
      "start": 427.816,
      "end": 429.316,
      "text": "有些地方讓人檢查",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 286,
      "start": 429.316,
      "end": 431.083,
      "text": "但最核心的技術能力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 287,
      "start": 431.083,
      "end": 432.816,
      "text": "又不能一次交出去",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 288,
      "start": 432.816,
      "end": 433.55,
      "text": "你會發現",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 289,
      "start": 433.55,
      "end": 435.183,
      "text": "出海越來越不像",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 290,
      "start": 435.183,
      "end": 436.316,
      "text": "單純賣產品",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 291,
      "start": 436.316,
      "end": 437.516,
      "text": "更像在不同國家",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 292,
      "start": 437.516,
      "end": 438.55,
      "text": "重新搭一個",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 293,
      "start": 438.55,
      "end": 439.583,
      "text": "版本的自己",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 294,
      "start": 439.683,
      "end": 441.25,
      "text": "這件事最大的後果",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 295,
      "start": 441.25,
      "end": 444.083,
      "text": "就是全球化會越來越貴",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 296,
      "start": 444.083,
      "end": 445.316,
      "text": "過去全球互聯網",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 297,
      "start": 445.316,
      "end": 446.95,
      "text": "最舒服的狀態是甚麼",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 298,
      "start": 446.95,
      "end": 447.816,
      "text": "一套系統",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 299,
      "start": 447.816,
      "end": 448.616,
      "text": "一個後台",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 300,
      "start": 448.616,
      "end": 449.516,
      "text": "一個總部",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 301,
      "start": 449.55,
      "end": 450.85,
      "text": "全世界一起跑",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 302,
      "start": 450.85,
      "end": 452.316,
      "text": "成本低效率高",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 303,
      "start": 452.316,
      "end": 453.616,
      "text": "以後可能變成",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 304,
      "start": 453.616,
      "end": 454.25,
      "text": "到了美國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 305,
      "start": 454.25,
      "end": 456.416,
      "text": "有一套美國的數據和治理",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 306,
      "start": 456.416,
      "end": 457.216,
      "text": "到了歐洲",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 307,
      "start": 457.216,
      "end": 458.516,
      "text": "又有歐洲的版本",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 308,
      "start": 458.516,
      "end": 459.75,
      "text": "去了其他市場",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 309,
      "start": 459.75,
      "end": 461.416,
      "text": "還得重新調整",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 310,
      "start": 461.416,
      "end": 463.25,
      "text": "品牌看起來還是一個",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 311,
      "start": 463.283,
      "end": 465.75,
      "text": "裡面卻已經分成很多房間",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 312,
      "start": 465.75,
      "end": 467.716,
      "text": "每個房間有自己的鎖",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 313,
      "start": 467.716,
      "end": 469.216,
      "text": "這對大公司還可以",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 314,
      "start": 469.216,
      "end": 470.35,
      "text": "大公司有錢",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 315,
      "start": 470.35,
      "end": 472.216,
      "text": "有律師有技術團隊",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 316,
      "start": 472.216,
      "end": 473.483,
      "text": "有安全團隊",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 317,
      "start": 473.483,
      "end": 475.85,
      "text": "也養得起當地管理機構",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 318,
      "start": 475.85,
      "end": 477.816,
      "text": "可中小公司就很難",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 319,
      "start": 477.883,
      "end": 479.083,
      "text": "一家創業公司",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 320,
      "start": 479.083,
      "end": 480.216,
      "text": "產品剛做起來",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 321,
      "start": 480.216,
      "end": 481.416,
      "text": "還沒賺多少錢",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 322,
      "start": 481.416,
      "end": 482.916,
      "text": "就讓它在三個國家",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 323,
      "start": 482.916,
      "end": 484.716,
      "text": "搭三套合規體系",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 324,
      "start": 484.716,
      "end": 486.583,
      "text": "它可能根本撐不住",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 325,
      "start": 486.616,
      "end": 487.416,
      "text": "所以TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 326,
      "start": 487.416,
      "end": 488.683,
      "text": "這條第三條路",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 327,
      "start": 488.683,
      "end": 490.45,
      "text": "並不代表科技全球化",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 328,
      "start": 490.45,
      "end": 491.75,
      "text": "從此更容易",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 329,
      "start": 491.75,
      "end": 493.116,
      "text": "很可能正好相反",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 330,
      "start": 493.116,
      "end": 494.45,
      "text": "全球市場還在",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 331,
      "start": 494.45,
      "end": 495.316,
      "text": "但進入全球",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 332,
      "start": 495.316,
      "end": 497.216,
      "text": "市場的門票變貴了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 333,
      "start": 497.216,
      "end": 498.483,
      "text": "而且門票越貴",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 334,
      "start": 498.483,
      "end": 500.05,
      "text": "大公司越佔優勢",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 335,
      "start": 500.05,
      "end": 502.116,
      "text": "這個現象蠻值得注意",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 336,
      "start": 502.116,
      "end": 503.25,
      "text": "我們平常覺得",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 337,
      "start": 503.25,
      "end": 505.716,
      "text": "監管主要是在限制大公司",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 338,
      "start": 505.716,
      "end": 507.083,
      "text": "可當監管複雜到",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 339,
      "start": 507.083,
      "end": 508.55,
      "text": "一定程度以後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 340,
      "start": 508.55,
      "end": 510.116,
      "text": "反而可能變成",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 341,
      "start": 510.216,
      "end": 511.75,
      "text": "大公司的護城河",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 342,
      "start": 511.75,
      "end": 513.316,
      "text": "因為同樣一套規則",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 343,
      "start": 513.316,
      "end": 515.016,
      "text": "大公司一年花",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 344,
      "start": 515.016,
      "end": 516.816,
      "text": "幾億元也許只是成本",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 345,
      "start": 516.816,
      "end": 517.883,
      "text": "小公司花不起",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 346,
      "start": 517.883,
      "end": 519.95,
      "text": "就只能放棄那個市場",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 347,
      "start": 519.95,
      "end": 521.916,
      "text": "所以未來科技競爭的門檻",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 348,
      "start": 521.95,
      "end": 523.483,
      "text": "可能不只是技術",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 349,
      "start": 523.483,
      "end": 524.45,
      "text": "還有一整套",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 350,
      "start": 524.45,
      "end": 525.65,
      "text": "處理不同國家",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 351,
      "start": 525.65,
      "end": 526.75,
      "text": "監管的能力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 352,
      "start": 526.75,
      "end": 527.783,
      "text": "再往後看",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 353,
      "start": 527.85,
      "end": 528.65,
      "text": "這種變化其實",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 354,
      "start": 528.65,
      "end": 530.016,
      "text": "不只發生在美國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 355,
      "start": 530.016,
      "end": 531.083,
      "text": "中國自己也很",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 356,
      "start": 531.083,
      "end": 532.316,
      "text": "熟悉類似邏輯",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 357,
      "start": 532.316,
      "end": 533.65,
      "text": "蘋果在中國大陸",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 358,
      "start": 533.65,
      "end": 535.15,
      "text": "提供雲服務時",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 359,
      "start": 535.216,
      "end": 536.85,
      "text": "中國用戶的相關數據",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 360,
      "start": 536.85,
      "end": 538.983,
      "text": "就要按照中國本地規則",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 361,
      "start": 539.016,
      "end": 540.316,
      "text": "在當地體系運營",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 362,
      "start": 540.316,
      "end": 542.216,
      "text": "當然這和TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 363,
      "start": 542.216,
      "end": 543.55,
      "text": "今天這套安排",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 364,
      "start": 543.55,
      "end": 545.05,
      "text": "並不是同一件事",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 365,
      "start": 545.05,
      "end": 547.016,
      "text": "TikTok牽涉得更深",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 366,
      "start": 547.016,
      "end": 547.816,
      "text": "除了數據",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 367,
      "start": 547.816,
      "end": 548.75,
      "text": "還有內容",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 368,
      "start": 548.75,
      "end": 549.65,
      "text": "推薦系統",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 369,
      "start": 549.65,
      "end": 550.716,
      "text": "代碼安全",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 370,
      "start": 550.716,
      "end": 551.516,
      "text": "但兩件事",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 371,
      "start": 551.516,
      "end": 553.283,
      "text": "背後的方向很接近",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 372,
      "start": 553.283,
      "end": 554.716,
      "text": "數字時代走到今天",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 373,
      "start": 554.716,
      "end": 555.983,
      "text": "各國政府越來越",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 374,
      "start": 555.983,
      "end": 557.15,
      "text": "不滿足於企業一句",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 375,
      "start": 557.15,
      "end": 559.45,
      "text": "你放心我會保護你的用戶",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 376,
      "start": 559.483,
      "end": 560.783,
      "text": "政府會繼續問",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 377,
      "start": 560.783,
      "end": 562.116,
      "text": "數據到底在哪裡",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 378,
      "start": 562.116,
      "end": 564.216,
      "text": "誰能看誰能改系統",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 379,
      "start": 564.216,
      "end": 566.016,
      "text": "出了問題誰負責",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 380,
      "start": 566.016,
      "end": 566.883,
      "text": "所以我覺得",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 381,
      "start": 566.883,
      "end": 568.216,
      "text": "未來真正改變",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 382,
      "start": 568.216,
      "end": 569.616,
      "text": "全球科技產業的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 383,
      "start": 569.616,
      "end": 571.45,
      "text": "可能不是簡單的脫鈎",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 384,
      "start": 571.616,
      "end": 573.583,
      "text": "而是一種更麻煩的狀態",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 385,
      "start": 573.75,
      "end": 575.416,
      "text": "生意繼續全球化",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 386,
      "start": 575.416,
      "end": 577.483,
      "text": "敏感權力開始本地化",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 387,
      "start": 577.483,
      "end": 579.316,
      "text": "公司還是全球公司",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 388,
      "start": 579.416,
      "end": 580.416,
      "text": "錢還是跨國賺",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 389,
      "start": 580.516,
      "end": 582.55,
      "text": "用戶也可能繼續連接",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 390,
      "start": 582.55,
      "end": 583.416,
      "text": "但是數據",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 391,
      "start": 583.45,
      "end": 585.45,
      "text": "算法運行和安全責任",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 392,
      "start": 585.45,
      "end": 586.483,
      "text": "會越來越被",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 393,
      "start": 586.483,
      "end": 588.55,
      "text": "各國抓回自己手裡",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 394,
      "start": 588.55,
      "end": 590.916,
      "text": "這其實比完全脫鈎更複雜",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 395,
      "start": 590.916,
      "end": 592.283,
      "text": "因為脫鈎很簡單",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 396,
      "start": 592.283,
      "end": 593.083,
      "text": "你走你的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 397,
      "start": 593.083,
      "end": 594.116,
      "text": "我走我的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 398,
      "start": 594.116,
      "end": 595.116,
      "text": "現在反而是",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 399,
      "start": 595.116,
      "end": 596.283,
      "text": "生意還要做",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 400,
      "start": 596.283,
      "end": 598.25,
      "text": "可我又不完全信任你",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 401,
      "start": 598.25,
      "end": 600.416,
      "text": "於是雙方只能一直畫邊界",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 402,
      "start": 600.483,
      "end": 601.283,
      "text": "哪裡歸你",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 403,
      "start": 601.283,
      "end": 602.316,
      "text": "哪裡歸我",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 404,
      "start": 602.316,
      "end": 603.483,
      "text": "甚麼能跨境",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 405,
      "start": 603.483,
      "end": 605.016,
      "text": "甚麼不能跨境",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 406,
      "start": 605.016,
      "end": 606.05,
      "text": "這才是TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 407,
      "start": 606.05,
      "end": 607.35,
      "text": "這件事真正有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 408,
      "start": 607.35,
      "end": 608.85,
      "text": "長期價值的地方",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 409,
      "start": 608.85,
      "end": 609.65,
      "text": "它不是證明",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 410,
      "start": 609.65,
      "end": 611.25,
      "text": "中美科技戰結束了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 411,
      "start": 611.25,
      "end": 612.283,
      "text": "恰恰相反",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 412,
      "start": 612.283,
      "end": 613.816,
      "text": "它可能說明中美科技戰",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 413,
      "start": 613.816,
      "end": 615.55,
      "text": "正在從一個很粗的階段",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 414,
      "start": 615.583,
      "end": 617.216,
      "text": "進入一個更細的階段",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 415,
      "start": 617.216,
      "end": 618.816,
      "text": "過去爭讓不讓你進",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 416,
      "start": 618.816,
      "end": 620.383,
      "text": "以後爭你進來以後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 417,
      "start": 620.383,
      "end": 621.716,
      "text": "到底能做什麼",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 418,
      "start": 621.716,
      "end": 622.916,
      "text": "這對美國自己其實",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 419,
      "start": 622.916,
      "end": 624.216,
      "text": "也不是沒有成本",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 420,
      "start": 624.216,
      "end": 625.316,
      "text": "很多人會覺得",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 421,
      "start": 625.316,
      "end": 627.316,
      "text": "美國要求數據留在美國",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 422,
      "start": 627.316,
      "end": 629.083,
      "text": "代碼讓甲骨文檢查",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 423,
      "start": 629.083,
      "end": 630.483,
      "text": "那不是很簡單嗎",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 424,
      "start": 630.483,
      "end": 632.15,
      "text": "其實長期監管一家",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 425,
      "start": 632.183,
      "end": 634.35,
      "text": "科技公司比直接封掉它",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 426,
      "start": 634.383,
      "end": 635.35,
      "text": "麻煩多了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 427,
      "start": 635.383,
      "end": 636.75,
      "text": "封是一次動作",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 428,
      "start": 636.783,
      "end": 638.816,
      "text": "管是每天都有事情",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 429,
      "start": 638.816,
      "end": 640.116,
      "text": "今天代碼檢查完",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 430,
      "start": 640.116,
      "end": 641.95,
      "text": "明天產品又更新",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 431,
      "start": 641.983,
      "end": 643.683,
      "text": "這個月算法是這個版本",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 432,
      "start": 643.683,
      "end": 645.016,
      "text": "下個月又換了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 433,
      "start": 645.016,
      "end": 646.316,
      "text": "工程師也會換",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 434,
      "start": 646.316,
      "end": 647.916,
      "text": "數據結構也會變",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 435,
      "start": 647.916,
      "end": 649.316,
      "text": "所以美國如果真的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 436,
      "start": 649.316,
      "end": 651.416,
      "text": "要靠這種模式長期管理",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 437,
      "start": 651.416,
      "end": 652.75,
      "text": "外國科技平台",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 438,
      "start": 652.783,
      "end": 655.416,
      "text": "它自己也得提高監管能力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 439,
      "start": 655.416,
      "end": 656.883,
      "text": "得有人看得懂代碼",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 440,
      "start": 656.883,
      "end": 657.95,
      "text": "有人懂算法",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 441,
      "start": 657.983,
      "end": 659.55,
      "text": "有人能夠判斷企業",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 442,
      "start": 659.583,
      "end": 661.083,
      "text": "有沒有繞過規則",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 443,
      "start": 661.083,
      "end": 662.983,
      "text": "這意味著雙方都要為",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 444,
      "start": 663.016,
      "end": 664.916,
      "text": "繼續做生意付新的成本",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 445,
      "start": 665.016,
      "end": 666.45,
      "text": "而這個成本可能就是",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 446,
      "start": 666.45,
      "end": 668.15,
      "text": "未來全球科技市場",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 447,
      "start": 668.183,
      "end": 669.683,
      "text": "最真實的樣子",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 448,
      "start": 669.683,
      "end": 671.25,
      "text": "它不會回到過去那種",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 449,
      "start": 671.25,
      "end": 672.883,
      "text": "毫無防備的全球化",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 450,
      "start": 672.883,
      "end": 674.65,
      "text": "但也未必一定走到",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 451,
      "start": 674.65,
      "end": 675.816,
      "text": "徹底切斷",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 452,
      "start": 675.816,
      "end": 677.65,
      "text": "中間會出現越來越多",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 453,
      "start": 677.65,
      "end": 679.116,
      "text": "這種奇怪的結構",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 454,
      "start": 679.216,
      "end": 680.95,
      "text": "我們不完全信任彼此",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 455,
      "start": 680.983,
      "end": 682.116,
      "text": "可是我們又捨不得",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 456,
      "start": 682.116,
      "end": 683.483,
      "text": "完全不做生意",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 457,
      "start": 683.483,
      "end": 685.816,
      "text": "所以只好一層一層加鎖",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 458,
      "start": 685.85,
      "end": 687.85,
      "text": "這件事情如果放回臺灣看",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 459,
      "start": 687.85,
      "end": 689.083,
      "text": "我覺得其實也很",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 460,
      "start": 689.083,
      "end": 690.116,
      "text": "值得想一下",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 461,
      "start": 690.116,
      "end": 692.05,
      "text": "臺灣討論科技產業的時候",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 462,
      "start": 692.05,
      "end": 693.283,
      "text": "很容易盯著一個",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 463,
      "start": 693.283,
      "end": 695.25,
      "text": "最直觀的東西工廠",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 464,
      "start": 695.283,
      "end": 696.35,
      "text": "廠有沒有搬",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 465,
      "start": 696.35,
      "end": 697.116,
      "text": "搬了幾座",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 466,
      "start": 697.116,
      "end": 699.083,
      "text": "美國又要建多少產能",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 467,
      "start": 699.083,
      "end": 700.516,
      "text": "這些當然重要",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 468,
      "start": 700.516,
      "end": 701.85,
      "text": "可是TikTok提醒了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 469,
      "start": 701.85,
      "end": 703.683,
      "text": "我們一個很現實的問題",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 470,
      "start": 703.683,
      "end": 705.55,
      "text": "看產業不要只看東西",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 471,
      "start": 705.55,
      "end": 706.316,
      "text": "搬到哪裡",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 472,
      "start": 706.316,
      "end": 708.283,
      "text": "還要看決定權搬到哪裡",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 473,
      "start": 708.283,
      "end": 709.25,
      "text": "比如半導體",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 474,
      "start": 709.25,
      "end": 711.116,
      "text": "下一代技術在哪裡研發",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 475,
      "start": 711.116,
      "end": 713.216,
      "text": "最厲害的工程師在哪裡",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 476,
      "start": 713.216,
      "end": 714.75,
      "text": "大客戶先跟誰談",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 477,
      "start": 714.783,
      "end": 716.35,
      "text": "產能最緊張的時候",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 478,
      "start": 716.35,
      "end": 718.383,
      "text": "誰決定先供給誰",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 479,
      "start": 718.416,
      "end": 720.516,
      "text": "下一輪投資由誰決定",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 480,
      "start": 720.516,
      "end": 721.75,
      "text": "這些比單純一座",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 481,
      "start": 721.783,
      "end": 723.95,
      "text": "廠房的位置更重要",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 482,
      "start": 723.95,
      "end": 726.05,
      "text": "所以臺灣企業去美國蓋廠",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 483,
      "start": 726.083,
      "end": 727.45,
      "text": "不代表核心能力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 484,
      "start": 727.45,
      "end": 728.516,
      "text": "隔天就沒了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 485,
      "start": 728.516,
      "end": 730.55,
      "text": "反過來總部還留在臺灣",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 486,
      "start": 730.616,
      "end": 732.616,
      "text": "也不代表所有核心權力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 487,
      "start": 732.616,
      "end": 733.65,
      "text": "永遠都在",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 488,
      "start": 733.65,
      "end": 735.083,
      "text": "真正應該看的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 489,
      "start": 735.083,
      "end": 737.016,
      "text": "是關鍵時刻還有沒有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 490,
      "start": 737.016,
      "end": 738.916,
      "text": "自己做決定的空間",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 491,
      "start": 738.916,
      "end": 740.35,
      "text": "人到中年其實很容易",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 492,
      "start": 740.35,
      "end": 741.25,
      "text": "懂這個道理",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 493,
      "start": 741.25,
      "end": 742.75,
      "text": "房子寫誰的名字",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 494,
      "start": 742.783,
      "end": 743.65,
      "text": "當然重要",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 495,
      "start": 743.65,
      "end": 745.283,
      "text": "可是一個家庭真正",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 496,
      "start": 745.283,
      "end": 746.35,
      "text": "有沒有自主",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 497,
      "start": 746.383,
      "end": 748.15,
      "text": "最後還要看重大事情",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 498,
      "start": 748.183,
      "end": 750.283,
      "text": "誰能決定錢誰能調度",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 499,
      "start": 750.283,
      "end": 752.116,
      "text": "出了問題誰還有退路",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 500,
      "start": 752.116,
      "end": 753.45,
      "text": "產業也一樣",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 501,
      "start": 753.45,
      "end": 755.083,
      "text": "有時候真正危險的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 502,
      "start": 755.083,
      "end": 757.016,
      "text": "不是東西出去一點",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 503,
      "start": 757.016,
      "end": 758.716,
      "text": "而是決定權出去以後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 504,
      "start": 758.716,
      "end": 760.45,
      "text": "就再也回不來了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 505,
      "start": 760.45,
      "end": 762.15,
      "text": "所以放回臺灣的位置看",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 506,
      "start": 762.183,
      "end": 763.916,
      "text": "未來真正該守的不是",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 507,
      "start": 763.916,
      "end": 764.95,
      "text": "什麼都不能動",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 508,
      "start": 764.983,
      "end": 766.483,
      "text": "而是那些一旦失去",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 509,
      "start": 766.483,
      "end": 767.516,
      "text": "就會讓自己沒有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 510,
      "start": 767.516,
      "end": 768.85,
      "text": "選擇的東西",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 511,
      "start": 768.85,
      "end": 769.883,
      "text": "這也是為什麼",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 512,
      "start": 769.883,
      "end": 771.216,
      "text": "我覺得現在還不能",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 513,
      "start": 771.216,
      "end": 772.083,
      "text": "急著宣布",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 514,
      "start": 772.083,
      "end": 773.516,
      "text": "TikTok的新規則",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 515,
      "start": 773.516,
      "end": 774.55,
      "text": "已經成功了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 516,
      "start": 774.583,
      "end": 776.483,
      "text": "這件事很適合用易經",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 517,
      "start": 776.483,
      "end": 778.65,
      "text": "裡面的未濟來理解",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 518,
      "start": 778.65,
      "end": 780.316,
      "text": "未濟不是失敗",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 519,
      "start": 780.316,
      "end": 781.683,
      "text": "它講的是事情已經",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 520,
      "start": 781.683,
      "end": 782.55,
      "text": "走到後面",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 521,
      "start": 782.583,
      "end": 784.083,
      "text": "看起來快完成了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 522,
      "start": 784.083,
      "end": 785.55,
      "text": "但新的狀態還沒",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 523,
      "start": 785.583,
      "end": 786.65,
      "text": "真正站穩",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 524,
      "start": 786.65,
      "end": 787.616,
      "text": "TikTok現在",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 525,
      "start": 787.616,
      "end": 788.283,
      "text": "就是這樣",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 526,
      "start": 788.283,
      "end": 789.283,
      "text": "交易落地",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 527,
      "start": 789.283,
      "end": 790.216,
      "text": "禁令撤掉",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 528,
      "start": 790.216,
      "end": 791.483,
      "text": "最危險的階段",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 529,
      "start": 791.483,
      "end": 792.683,
      "text": "好像過去了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 530,
      "start": 792.683,
      "end": 794.25,
      "text": "可是這套安排到底",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 531,
      "start": 794.25,
      "end": 796.383,
      "text": "能不能變成真正的規則",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 532,
      "start": 796.383,
      "end": 797.916,
      "text": "我覺得接下來只要",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 533,
      "start": 797.916,
      "end": 799.816,
      "text": "看三個問題就夠了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 534,
      "start": 799.816,
      "end": 801.716,
      "text": "第一個能不能複製",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 535,
      "start": 801.716,
      "end": 803.35,
      "text": "下一家中國科技企業",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 536,
      "start": 803.383,
      "end": 804.65,
      "text": "遇到類似問題",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 537,
      "start": 804.65,
      "end": 806.216,
      "text": "美國還願不願意談",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 538,
      "start": 806.216,
      "end": 807.85,
      "text": "這種本地治理方案",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 539,
      "start": 807.85,
      "end": 809.016,
      "text": "如果只有TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 540,
      "start": 809.016,
      "end": 809.816,
      "text": "一個特例",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 541,
      "start": 809.816,
      "end": 811.283,
      "text": "那它就不是規則",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 542,
      "start": 811.283,
      "end": 813.65,
      "text": "第二個能不能跨政府延續",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 543,
      "start": 813.65,
      "end": 815.216,
      "text": "美國換一屆政府以後",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 544,
      "start": 815.216,
      "end": 817.15,
      "text": "這套辦法還能不能繼續",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 545,
      "start": 817.283,
      "end": 818.483,
      "text": "如果每換一次人",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 546,
      "start": 818.483,
      "end": 819.916,
      "text": "就全部推倒重來",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 547,
      "start": 819.916,
      "end": 822.116,
      "text": "那它只是一次政治交易",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 548,
      "start": 822.116,
      "end": 823.883,
      "text": "第三個能不能經得起",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 549,
      "start": 823.883,
      "end": 824.95,
      "text": "真正的事故",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 550,
      "start": 824.983,
      "end": 826.483,
      "text": "平常沒有問題的時候",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 551,
      "start": 826.483,
      "end": 828.816,
      "text": "任何制度看起來都很好",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 552,
      "start": 828.816,
      "end": 830.25,
      "text": "如果以後真的出現",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 553,
      "start": 830.25,
      "end": 832.15,
      "text": "數據爭議算法爭議",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 554,
      "start": 832.183,
      "end": 833.35,
      "text": "安全事故",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 555,
      "start": 833.35,
      "end": 835.65,
      "text": "這套本地治理能不能解決",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 556,
      "start": 835.65,
      "end": 837.516,
      "text": "而不是最後又回到一句",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 557,
      "start": 837.516,
      "end": 838.816,
      "text": "直接禁掉",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 558,
      "start": 838.816,
      "end": 840.516,
      "text": "只要這三關還沒過",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 559,
      "start": 840.516,
      "end": 842.416,
      "text": "現在就不能叫既濟",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 560,
      "start": 842.416,
      "end": 843.55,
      "text": "最多只能說",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 561,
      "start": 843.583,
      "end": 845.816,
      "text": "第三條路已經被走出來了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 562,
      "start": 845.816,
      "end": 847.183,
      "text": "但是這條路能不能",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 563,
      "start": 847.183,
      "end": 849.216,
      "text": "鋪成公路還不知道",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 564,
      "start": 849.216,
      "end": 851.216,
      "text": "這裡順便講一個最近",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 565,
      "start": 851.216,
      "end": 852.45,
      "text": "很容易被放在一起",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 566,
      "start": 852.45,
      "end": 853.45,
      "text": "解釋的事情",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 567,
      "start": 853.45,
      "end": 855.116,
      "text": "最近確實有中國企業",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 568,
      "start": 855.116,
      "end": 856.883,
      "text": "收到美國關稅退款",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 569,
      "start": 856.883,
      "end": 858.283,
      "text": "有些金額很大",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 570,
      "start": 858.283,
      "end": 859.683,
      "text": "但我不會把這件事",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 571,
      "start": 859.683,
      "end": 861.516,
      "text": "直接解釋成美國突然",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 572,
      "start": 861.516,
      "end": 863.116,
      "text": "對中國態度變好了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 573,
      "start": 863.116,
      "end": 864.683,
      "text": "這一輪退款最直接",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 574,
      "start": 864.683,
      "end": 867.216,
      "text": "的背景是美國司法裁決",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 575,
      "start": 867.216,
      "end": 868.95,
      "text": "推翻了此前一部分",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 576,
      "start": 868.983,
      "end": 869.85,
      "text": "關稅授權",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 577,
      "start": 869.883,
      "end": 871.35,
      "text": "後面依法處理退款",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 578,
      "start": 871.383,
      "end": 872.883,
      "text": "它首先是法律結果",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 579,
      "start": 872.883,
      "end": 874.016,
      "text": "不是美國突然",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 580,
      "start": 874.016,
      "end": 875.583,
      "text": "送出來的一份禮物",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 581,
      "start": 875.616,
      "end": 876.65,
      "text": "為什麼這個地方",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 582,
      "start": 876.65,
      "end": 877.516,
      "text": "要分清楚",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 583,
      "start": 877.516,
      "end": 879.283,
      "text": "因為我們看國際關係",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 584,
      "start": 879.283,
      "end": 880.483,
      "text": "很容易把所有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 585,
      "start": 880.483,
      "end": 881.816,
      "text": "對自己有利的事情",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 586,
      "start": 881.816,
      "end": 884.216,
      "text": "都解釋成對方服軟了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 587,
      "start": 884.25,
      "end": 885.05,
      "text": "這樣講很爽",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 588,
      "start": 885.05,
      "end": 887.383,
      "text": "可是很容易看錯下一步",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 589,
      "start": 887.383,
      "end": 888.65,
      "text": "TikTok也是一樣",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 590,
      "start": 888.65,
      "end": 890.45,
      "text": "我覺得它真正的價值",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 591,
      "start": 890.45,
      "end": 892.683,
      "text": "不是證明美國被誰打服",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 592,
      "start": 892.683,
      "end": 893.75,
      "text": "而是證明一件",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 593,
      "start": 893.783,
      "end": 895.35,
      "text": "更現實的事情",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 594,
      "start": 895.35,
      "end": 897.55,
      "text": "當徹底封殺的成本太高",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 595,
      "start": 897.583,
      "end": 899.016,
      "text": "而企業又不可能",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 596,
      "start": 899.016,
      "end": 900.316,
      "text": "什麼都不讓的時候",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 597,
      "start": 900.316,
      "end": 902.016,
      "text": "中間確實可能談出",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 598,
      "start": 902.016,
      "end": 903.416,
      "text": "一種新的分法",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 599,
      "start": 903.416,
      "end": 904.35,
      "text": "美國沒有拿到",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 600,
      "start": 904.35,
      "end": 905.75,
      "text": "最理想的TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 601,
      "start": 905.783,
      "end": 907.083,
      "text": "TikTok也沒有保住",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 602,
      "start": 907.083,
      "end": 908.716,
      "text": "原來的所有控制權",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 603,
      "start": 908.716,
      "end": 910.283,
      "text": "雙方都讓了一些",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 604,
      "start": 910.283,
      "end": 911.75,
      "text": "可雙方也都保住了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 605,
      "start": 911.75,
      "end": 914.316,
      "text": "自己最不能失去的那一塊",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 606,
      "start": 914.316,
      "end": 915.783,
      "text": "這種結果看起來沒有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 607,
      "start": 915.816,
      "end": 917.55,
      "text": "誰徹底贏了那麼刺激",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 608,
      "start": 917.583,
      "end": 918.883,
      "text": "但它反而更像",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 609,
      "start": 918.883,
      "end": 921.183,
      "text": "真正能長期存在的規則",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 610,
      "start": 921.183,
      "end": 922.616,
      "text": "因為國家之間很多",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 611,
      "start": 922.616,
      "end": 923.816,
      "text": "穩定的邊界",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 612,
      "start": 923.816,
      "end": 925.35,
      "text": "就是這麼長出來的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 613,
      "start": 925.383,
      "end": 927.25,
      "text": "不是因為突然互相信任",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 614,
      "start": 927.25,
      "end": 928.85,
      "text": "而是因為彼此都發現",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 615,
      "start": 928.916,
      "end": 930.116,
      "text": "再往前一步",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 616,
      "start": 930.116,
      "end": 931.983,
      "text": "自己也要付代價",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 617,
      "start": 932.05,
      "end": 933.283,
      "text": "所以回到最開始",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 618,
      "start": 933.283,
      "end": 934.283,
      "text": "TikTok解禁",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 619,
      "start": 934.283,
      "end": 935.783,
      "text": "當然是一條新聞",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 620,
      "start": 935.816,
      "end": 937.316,
      "text": "但幾年以後如果我們",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 621,
      "start": 937.316,
      "end": 938.316,
      "text": "再回頭看",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 622,
      "start": 938.316,
      "end": 940.516,
      "text": "真正重要的也許不是",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 623,
      "start": 940.516,
      "end": 942.05,
      "text": "2026年美國政府",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 624,
      "start": 942.05,
      "end": 943.55,
      "text": "設備上終於又能使用",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 625,
      "start": 943.55,
      "end": 944.183,
      "text": "TikTok",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 626,
      "start": 944.183,
      "end": 945.45,
      "text": "而是另外一件事",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 627,
      "start": 945.45,
      "end": 946.516,
      "text": "過去那道只有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 628,
      "start": 946.516,
      "end": 947.483,
      "text": "兩個選項的門",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 629,
      "start": 947.483,
      "end": 949.116,
      "text": "賣掉或者退出",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 630,
      "start": 949.116,
      "end": 950.95,
      "text": "第一次被擠出了一條",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 631,
      "start": 950.983,
      "end": 952.716,
      "text": "真正存在的縫",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 632,
      "start": 952.716,
      "end": 953.85,
      "text": "生意可以繼續",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 633,
      "start": 953.85,
      "end": 956.05,
      "text": "但關鍵權力要重新談",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 634,
      "start": 956.05,
      "end": 957.116,
      "text": "不同市場可能有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 635,
      "start": 957.116,
      "end": 958.016,
      "text": "不同的邊界",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 636,
      "start": 958.016,
      "end": 959.616,
      "text": "這條縫現在還不寬",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 637,
      "start": 959.616,
      "end": 960.683,
      "text": "能不能走成一條",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 638,
      "start": 960.683,
      "end": 961.55,
      "text": "穩定的路",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 639,
      "start": 961.583,
      "end": 963.016,
      "text": "也還沒有答案",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 640,
      "start": 963.016,
      "end": 964.216,
      "text": "可是只要它真的",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 641,
      "start": 964.216,
      "end": 965.316,
      "text": "存在過一次",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 642,
      "start": 965.316,
      "end": 966.883,
      "text": "以後面對類似事件",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 643,
      "start": 966.883,
      "end": 968.55,
      "text": "我們就可以少問一句",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 644,
      "start": 968.583,
      "end": 969.883,
      "text": "到底誰贏了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 645,
      "start": 969.883,
      "end": 970.816,
      "text": "多問一句",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 646,
      "start": 970.816,
      "end": 972.116,
      "text": "最後誰還保留",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 647,
      "start": 972.116,
      "end": 973.783,
      "text": "調整自己的能力",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 648,
      "start": 973.883,
      "end": 975.25,
      "text": "因為真正的被動",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 649,
      "start": 975.25,
      "end": 976.883,
      "text": "從來不是少賺一點",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 650,
      "start": 976.883,
      "end": 977.883,
      "text": "也不是退一步",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 651,
      "start": 977.883,
      "end": 979.683,
      "text": "而是有一天局勢變了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 652,
      "start": 979.683,
      "end": 980.516,
      "text": "你才發現",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 653,
      "start": 980.616,
      "end": 982.083,
      "text": "自己手裡已經沒有",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    },
    {
      "id": 654,
      "start": 982.083,
      "end": 984.0,
      "text": "可以重新選擇的東西了",
      "source": "video_source_subtitle",
      "authority": "video_source_subtitle",
      "timing_source": "manual_global_offset"
    }
  ],
  "transcript_selection": {
    "schema": "videonote.transcript_selection.v1",
    "status": "SELECTED",
    "requested_language": "zh",
    "duration": 984.0,
    "reference_path": "/Users/sagawa/AI_WORK/video_notes/url/20260813_120220__TikTok真正重要的根本不是解禁_中美科技戰突然多出第三條路_下一家中國科技公司也能這麼談/reference_subtitle.vtt",
    "reference_kind": "manual",
    "reference_language": "zh-Hans",
    "selected_source": "video_source_subtitle",
    "decision_reason": "complete_manual_source_subtitle_fast_path_no_whisper",
    "whisper_rejected": false,
    "source_profile": {
      "segment_count": 655,
      "duration_coverage": 0.994933
    }
  },
  "manual_timeline_offset": {
    "seconds": 0.25,
    "applied_at": "2026-08-13T12:49:01.845560+00:00"
  }
}